Comments on: What’s the Best Viewing Order For the Saga? http://www.jedinet.com/prequels/whats-the-best-viewing-order-for-the-saga Star Wars News For the Fans, By the Fans Tue, 18 Nov 2008 15:04:02 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.3 By: Findingneo http://www.jedinet.com/prequels/whats-the-best-viewing-order-for-the-saga#comment-31 Findingneo Wed, 29 Nov 2006 16:04:33 +0000 http://www.jedinet.com/?p=22#comment-31 While I think the Alternating version is the best... I feel it should be changed a tad to this ordering: IV First, no plot is really given that ruins either trilogy, only questions really. What was the Senate? How did the Jedi get destroyed? Why is that saber fight so... well bad? What was the Clone Wars? Next, watch I and II, for what they have in special affects they make up for in subpar acting which will be absent throughout the rest of the viewing experience. Questions are answered, Senate is this, Clone Wars were this, Saber fights used to be awesome, look at Old Ben rock this Sith mofo. etc. Go back to V, new question, Vader is Luke's daddy? WTF? O snap! It's the bad guy from before! He's really old and decrepid isn't he? How did he become ruler of the galaxy? This is so messed up shit! Epsiode III, those questions are ALL answered, with good special effects and acting to boot. Episode VI, That's right Vader! Redeem yourself! You used to be nice and have a family and what not! Don't be a dead beat dad!<div class="comment-remix-meta"><a href="#" class="replyto" onclick="replyto('31','Findingneo'); return false;">Reply</a> - <a href="#" class="quote" onclick="quote('31','Findingneo','While I think the Alternating version is the best... I feel it should be changed a tad to this ordering:\n\nIV First, no plot is really given that ruins either trilogy, only questions really. What was the Senate? How did the Jedi get destroyed? Why is that saber fight so... well bad? What was the Clone Wars?\n\nNext, watch I and II, for what they have in special affects they make up for in subpar acting which will be absent throughout the rest of the viewing experience. Questions are answered, Senate is this, Clone Wars were this, Saber fights used to be awesome, look at Old Ben rock this Sith mofo. etc.\n\nGo back to V, new question, Vader is Luke\'s daddy? WTF? O snap! It\'s the bad guy from before! He\'s really old and decrepid isn\'t he? How did he become ruler of the galaxy? This is so messed up shit!\n\nEpsiode III, those questions are ALL answered, with good special effects and acting to boot.\n\nEpisode VI, That\'s right Vader! Redeem yourself! You used to be nice and have a family and what not! Don\'t be a dead beat dad!'); return false;">Quote</a></div> While I think the Alternating version is the best… I feel it should be changed a tad to this ordering:

IV First, no plot is really given that ruins either trilogy, only questions really. What was the Senate? How did the Jedi get destroyed? Why is that saber fight so… well bad? What was the Clone Wars?

Next, watch I and II, for what they have in special affects they make up for in subpar acting which will be absent throughout the rest of the viewing experience. Questions are answered, Senate is this, Clone Wars were this, Saber fights used to be awesome, look at Old Ben rock this Sith mofo. etc.

Go back to V, new question, Vader is Luke’s daddy? WTF? O snap! It’s the bad guy from before! He’s really old and decrepid isn’t he? How did he become ruler of the galaxy? This is so messed up shit!

Epsiode III, those questions are ALL answered, with good special effects and acting to boot.

Episode VI, That’s right Vader! Redeem yourself! You used to be nice and have a family and what not! Don’t be a dead beat dad!

Reply - Quote
]]> By: aPPmaSTer http://www.jedinet.com/prequels/whats-the-best-viewing-order-for-the-saga#comment-30 aPPmaSTer Tue, 07 Nov 2006 15:45:40 +0000 http://www.jedinet.com/?p=22#comment-30 Yeah, I can see the logic in the flashback mode, and I find it quite interesting myself. I was always a fan of the production order, but this one is a fresh new idea that I think I'll seriously consider trying once... It also wouldn't be bad if they fixed ROTJ up a bit to be a better finale. There are some problems with lightsabers, etc. as well as some continuity issues that will need intevening for any coming release of the movies.<div class="comment-remix-meta"><a href="#" class="replyto" onclick="replyto('30','aPPmaSTer'); return false;">Reply</a> - <a href="#" class="quote" onclick="quote('30','aPPmaSTer','Yeah, I can see the logic in the flashback mode, and I find it quite interesting myself. I was always a fan of the production order, but this one is a fresh new idea that I think I\'ll seriously consider trying once...\n\nIt also wouldn\'t be bad if they fixed ROTJ up a bit to be a better finale. There are some problems with lightsabers, etc. as well as some continuity issues that will need intevening for any coming release of the movies.'); return false;">Quote</a></div> Yeah, I can see the logic in the flashback mode, and I find it quite interesting myself. I was always a fan of the production order, but this one is a fresh new idea that I think I’ll seriously consider trying once…

It also wouldn’t be bad if they fixed ROTJ up a bit to be a better finale. There are some problems with lightsabers, etc. as well as some continuity issues that will need intevening for any coming release of the movies.

Reply - Quote
]]>